Fasting and Weight Loss

By Kevin Richardson, Founder of The Naturally Intense System of Diet & Exercise™

Benjamin Franklin once said that the best medicine is resting and fasting and that my be so, but fasting and weight loss however is an entirely different story. In my career over the past several decades as a personal trainer I am have often been asked about fasting as a tool for weight loss and many people use it as a way to try to shed a few extra pounds here and there. In this article I am going to highlight the drawbacks to using fasting as a method of weight control as it performs rather poorly as a long term weight management tool.

Fasting is defined as an abstinence of some sort with regard to food and water, and is done usually for either spiritual reasons or in some circles as a means of improving overall health. Spiritual fasting is very much a mainstay of almost every major religious sect, and can have profound benefits as a spiritual experience. That being said, this article does not address fasting of this nature, which I firmly believe in and practice myself, however it does tackle several important myths regarding fasting for health purposes. There are three main reasons given for fasting to improve health, and most of them are almost universally accepted as being true.

1. Fasting gives your digestive system time to rest and recover from the strain of processing food.

2. Fasting helps the body get rid of unwanted toxins.

3. Fasting helps you lose weight.

Fasting And Weight Loss Myth #1: Resting Your Organs

With regards to the first suggestion that your digestive system needs a rest, it seems like a very plausible idea, and most would agree that it sounds like a good idea. However our own rather linear logic does not always translate into physiological reality.

The human body is designed to process food as it is an ongoing requirement, as such it cannot be overworked from digesting the food that it needs to survive. Consider the analogy of a car, you would not give your car engine a rest by not putting any fuel in the gas tank and letting it run on empty? Similarly you cannot expect your body to function optimally if you do not give it the fuel it needs.

Now if you put contaminated or low quality fuel in your car, then you can indeed overwork the engine, and the same applies to the food you ingest. Thus if you want to ensure that your digestive system is never overwhelmed, then the focus should be on proper nutrition and avoiding junk foods and foods that the human body was not designed to process. Fasting is not the answer.

With regard to the elimination of toxins, again it sounds like a solid theory, however our organs are there to do just that- breakdown and remove toxins, and that they do a pretty good job of it. If you wanted to ensure that your liver or kidneys are not strained by any toxic build up, you would then do well to watch what you eat and not consume anything that might be harmful to your body.

Fasting And Weight Loss Myth # 2: Detoxifying Your Body

Staying away from alcohol, illegal drugs as well as abstaining from foods containing trans fats, monosodium glutamate, high levels of sodium and sugars, as well as processed foods will help you go a long way to prevent unwanted strain on you organs, whereas fasting will not.

Fasting And Weight Loss Myth # 3: Weight Loss

The use of fasting for weight loss is perhaps the most common reason among those I have spoken with over the years, and once again, common sense seems to agree that it is a good idea. If I just don't eat for long periods of time, I will lose weight. Sadly if it was that easy then we would not be facing the obesity epidemic here in the United States, in and in so many European countries.

It is usually the first thing people try when they want to lose some pounds, but not only does it not work, but is unhealthy and can actually make you fat! After only 12 hours of fasting, your body starts using stored glucose as a fuel and then beings breaking down protein for energy in a process called gluconeogenesis. What is alarming about this is that that protein comes from your muscles and as such you lose muscle whenever you fast for prolonged periods of time.

Also important to note is that when your body does not have a steady supply of food, it beings to think that it is in a state of famine. As a way of protecting itself, your body then slows down your metabolism to conserve calories which is exactly what you do not want to happen. Additionally a study printed in The Journal of Nutrition reported that even 10 to 12 hours of not eating can lead to a loss of calcium, the mineral needed for strong bones and teeth. Lack of calcium leads to loss of bone mass and osteoporosis, and is especially dangerous for those over the age of forty and for those under twenty, whose bones are still in development. After 24 hours fasting can reduce blood sugar levels by as much as 50%, which places a severe amount of stress on your system.

There Are No Real Health Benefits To Fasting

To summarize, there are no real health benefits to fasting and I would recommend strongly against doing it for those reasons. Many claim as well that fasting gives them a higher state of awareness and makes them feel ‘lighter’, however this is simply as a result of glucose depletion, which has an almost alcohol like effect on the brain. As someone engaged in intense physical exercise, fasting is certainly counterproductive and dangerous, in that the confusion caused by low blood sugar levels makes it harder for you to concentrate, thus increasing your likelihood of injury, and instead of benefiting from your workouts, your body will instead cannibalize your existing muscle tissue.

Information contained in this article is not meant to treat, diagnose illness, nor substitute for medical counsel and is intended for purposes of information and education only. Consult your physician before modifying your diet or starting any exercise program. Copyright 2009 by Kevin Richardson, Naturally Intense Personal Trainer NYC.

If you wish to print this review or read it offline at your leisure, right click on the link below, and select "save as"

Fasting And Weight Loss

(Adobe Acrobat Required)

Controlling Your Eating Habits

Supermarket Shopping For Weight Loss

Weight Gain From Diet Soda

12 Diet Foods To Avoid
Good Carbs vs Bad Carbs

Join our mailing list for newsletters, weight loss tips & special offers!